1. Diverging visions

Enterprises thrive when there’s a single shared vision that drives their strategic direction. If co-founders begin to pull in different directions, misalignment can slow progress or even stall the business altogether.

2. Unequal commitment and contribution

Dedication is a key ingredient in building a successful brand. In the early stages, simply sharing responsibility is not enough. Team members often need to take 100% responsibility for their roles, and the same applies to founders. If one co-founder pulls more weight than the other, resentment can build up, leading to conflicts.

Whether due to personal commitments or a lack of ability, the resulting imbalance can undermine the startup’s potential. If expectations continue to go unmet and accountability is neglected, it may be time to let the extra weight go.

3. Persistent conflicts that impede business operations

It’s natural for business partners to have disagreements over certain aspects, but ongoing conflicts that affect day-to-day operations can be detrimental. If key decisions remain undecided due to repeated disputes or if the tension has become so high that it creates toxicity within the work environment, an amicable separation may be the only way to restore efficiency and boost team morale.

4. Unfair equity or compensation disputes

Another common point of contention between co-founders is the feeling that they are contributing more but receiving less for their efforts. If this disagreement is not resolved through negotiations, it can lead to long-term dissatisfaction, which can destabilise the company.

5. Differing risk tolerance and decision-making styles

Risk is inherent to building an enterprise. Startups require swift and often high-risk decision-making, such as adopting new technologies that can make or break the business. Some founders prefer to take bold risks, while others adopt a more conservative approach.

When co-founders are not united on this front, differences in risk appetite can create uncertainty. If this misalignment snowballs into a hindrance in seizing growth opportunities or adapting to crucial market shifts, the partnership may no longer be viable.

How to part ways professionally and legally

Here’s what should be done when handling a co-founder split.

1. Review the partnership agreement

The first step is to examine the original partnership or shareholder agreement. Ideally, this document should outline exit procedures, equity distribution and intellectual property ownership. If no formal agreement exists, co-founders should seek legal advice to navigate the separation within UK company law frameworks.

2. Negotiate buyout terms

If only one founder is exiting while the other continues with the brand, fair compensation is just and necessary. It’s not easy to sell shares – especially with an emotional attachment – but equity buybacks should be based on fair market value to reduce the negative consequences. At the same time, it should be structured in a way that does not place undue financial strain on the institution. Options may include lump-sum payments, phased buyouts or convertible notes.

3. Reallocate responsibilities and communicate clearly

A transition plan should be established to reassign the departing co-founder’s responsibilities. If they held a key leadership role, consider hiring a replacement or redistributing duties among the remaining leadership team. Transparent communication with employees, investors and key stakeholders is essential to maintaining confidence that the business will remain stable despite owner shifts.

4. Address intellectual property and ownership matters

Ensure all intellectual property created during the partnership is properly assigned. If necessary, update contracts to reflect changes in ownership or usage rights. Additionally, if the departing co-founder was a board member or held executive titles, ensure formal resignation documents are completed to prevent future governance complications.

5. Consider mediation or a neutral third party

Should negotiations go downhill and become contentious, bringing in a mediator or neutral advisor can facilitate a fair resolution. Mediation can help both parties agree on an overall decision and separate on good terms.

Moving forward after a co-founder split

Once the separation is finalised, the company must focus on regaining momentum. This includes transparent communication and assuring stakeholders that the outlook remains strong. Hence, a clear roadmap must be presented. Co-founder separations are challenging, but handling them professionally can help propel a brand to greater heights and prevent long-term damage.

For more startup news, check out the other articles on the website, and subscribe to the magazine for free. Listen to The Cereal Entrepreneur podcast for more interviews with entrepreneurs and big-hitters in the startup ecosystem.