The cost of data breaches: protecting small businesses from payment fraud
Payment data breaches are a threat with costly consequences for businesses. In fact, a major breach of a major payment system uncovered in September 2024 revealed that an unauthorised party accessed sensitive consumer data for nearly ten months. The compromised information included names, addresses, credit card details, expiration dates and more. Such incidents not only erode consumer trust but also leave businesses facing significant financial, legal and reputational repercussions.
For small businesses, this vulnerability can be particularly costly as they often lack the resources to recover quickly and are still in the process of building a strong brand reputation. A breach not only undermines customer trust but also hampers their ability to attract new clients and achieve long-term success. Being unprepared due to a lack of resources can transform a data breach from a challenge into a catastrophic risk.
As such, businesses must focus on implementing strong, strategic fraud prevention methods. Comprehensive cybersecurity can no longer be viewed by organisations as an afterthought, but rather a necessity that protects the future of the business.
The true impact of payment data breaches
Direct financial losses following a payment data breach because of fraudulent activity can be crippling for businesses. But unfortunately, this is only part of the problem. Everything from identifying and addressing the breach, to implementing new security measures and notifying affected customers can prove costly. Further financial loss often results from the disruption to daily operations.
In today’s environment where consumers are highly cautious about data privacy, many are likely to question the safety of every transaction and avoid businesses that have recently experienced a breach. While a single breach can damage trust in an individual business, it also undermines confidence in the digital payments' ecosystem, delaying the adoption of new financial technologies as consumers become hesitant to embrace innovations they perceive as vulnerable to threats.
The fallout from a breach can also lead to significant financial challenges that are especially tough for smaller businesses. In addition to fines, potential legal fees and the cost of upgrading security systems, businesses must also contend with rising fraud prevention expenses, which impact the bottom line for both the company and its consumers.
Emerging fraud trends
As technology advances, so do the tactics employed by cybercriminals, who are finding new ways to exploit vulnerabilities in both individuals and business systems. Phishing attacks remain one of the most prevalent and damaging forms of cybercrime for businesses. The attacks involve cybercriminals impersonating trusted entities, such as a bank, vendor or even an internal department, via email to trick victims into revealing sensitive information like login credentials or financial details. It only takes one employee falling for a well-crafted phishing email to trigger a major data breach or financial loss.
Another ongoing threat for businesses is card not present (CNP) fraud, where cybercriminals exploit stolen payment information to make unauthorised purchases in environments where a physical card isn't required. With the rise of eCommerce, CNP fraud is also increasing, resulting in costly chargebacks, financial strain and higher risk management expenses.
Account takeover fraud (ATO) is another growing concern for businesses. This is where a cybercriminal gains unauthorised access to a customer’s account and uses it to cause harm. They may make illegitimate purchases, steal stored payment information or change account settings, putting customers at further risk of identity theft. For businesses with an online presence – whether they’re retail sites, subscription services or membership-based platforms – the damage from an account takeover can extend beyond financial loss to include a serious decline in customer trust.
Building a comprehensive fraud prevention strategy
To counter these threats, businesses need to adopt a comprehensive fraud prevention strategy, combining a variety of tools and practices to create a robust defence. One essential component is multi-layered payment protection. By integrating multiple security measures into the payment process, businesses can effectively detect and block fraudulent transactions. Solutions like transaction scoring, device fingerprinting and address verification work together to identify suspicious activity that could be result of a data breach.
For organisations that handle customer accounts, implementing 3D Secure 2 and two-factor authentication (2FA) is a highly effective way to prevent unauthorised access and reduce fraud-related chargebacks. 3DS2 is an authentication protocol used by banks and financial institutions to secure online transactions and verify the identity of the card holder. 2FA adds another layer of security, requiring users to verify their identity through a combination of factors, such as an authentication code or mobile device.
Real-time monitoring tools also allow businesses to keep an eye on transactions and account activity as they happen, enabling them to identify and respond to threats instantly. Using advanced software, businesses can receive alerts for suspicious behaviour, giving business owners the opportunity to review and confirm transactions before any damage is done. In turn, this minimises losses and ensures the safety of customer data.
Finally, partnering with a trusted payment service provider (PSP) strengthens fraud prevention by offering advanced tools and customisable fraud protection settings and date security protection. These solutions help businesses quickly detect and block suspicious activity, minimising the risk of fraud and chargebacks. By leveraging a PSP's expertise, businesses can stay ahead of emerging threats while maintaining a seamless and secure customer experience.
Now is the time for businesses to act – implementing these vital fraud prevention measures can protect your business from potential threats, safeguard customer trust, and secure your bottom line.
By understanding the financial and reputational damage that payment data breaches can cause, developing an awareness of the latest fraud tactics, and implementing a robust, multi-layered security strategy, businesses can safeguard their assets and preserve customer trust. In today’s digital-first economy, those who prioritise data security won’t just survive – they will be positioned to lead, grow and thrive in an increasingly vulnerable e-commerce environment.
For more startup news, check out the other articles on the website, and subscribe to the magazine for free. Listen to The Cereal Entrepreneur podcast for more interviews with entrepreneurs and big-hitters in the startup ecosystem.