Free from the risk-based and prudent regulatory environment of the European Union, the UK needs to decide whether to follow suit, or embrace the US laissez-faire, pro-innovation framework moving forward. Striking the right balance is crucial, particularly for startups and SMEs, to foster a clear, stable regulatory framework in which early-stage companies can operate in an environment conducive to success.

The importance of regulating AI cannot be understated. AI technologies, such as large language models (LLMs), which are trained on public data, present distinct challenges in relation to safety, privacy, security, and bias. The rapid evolution of AI also adds complexity to the regulatory process, echoing the early challenges of social media, where technology outpaced regulation. Equally, the long-term impact of AI is impossible to predict, making it difficult to establish and impose clear guardrails. Despite this, companies working in the sector have immense potential to drive transformative change, so regulation that hampers their progress would certainly impact the UK’s global competitiveness, and the ecosystem of AI startups currently operating within the country.

The UK’s Conservative government favoured a light-touch approach to AI regulation, a stance that Labour has maintained upon their election in July of this year. With no general statutory regulation, AI is governed according to the specific requirements of each sector in the UK. This allows the government greater flexibility in responding to AI-related matters as they develop, while enabling a context-specific approach to address them effectively. The rejection of a blanket regulatory approach will allow incidents to be dealt with on a sector-by-sector basis, without hindering progress in preparation for an AI-related issue that may never arise.

The UK favouring innovation does not make it immune to external legislation, however. The UK is not under the scrutiny of the EU’s AI Act post-Brexit, but the remaining ties between the two jurisdictions means the UK cannot completely ignore the mandate. To ensure the free flow of data between the EU and the UK, companies operating in the UK must maintain certain agreements outlined in the AI Act to allow this to continue. Furthermore, the EU AI Office and the US AI Safety Institute often collaborate on discussions surrounding the safety and potential threats posed by AI. Although the UK are tied into these conversations, their lack of direct involvement risks marginalising their influence in decisions taken by their closest neighbours. The UK cannot afford to ignore these developments, and the conclusions drawn by the EU and US on AI will inevitably impact the UK as well.

The UK must develop balanced regulation that fosters innovation without placing undue emphasis on risk. Their current approach has proven effective so far, but diverging too much from EU standards could make operations between the two locations difficult. AI is one of the most pressing global challenges of our time, and fragmentation on the international stage must be avoided if the UK is to establish itself as a leader in the sector.

While competition drives innovation, cooperation is equally important. A coordinated approach with the EU could ensure the smooth running of operations, attract startups seeking a stable AI landscape, and position the UK as a compelling alternative to the US. The UK government must also ensure that lobbying from Big Tech corporations does not overshadow the voices of startups in the space. Neglecting the needs of smaller firms while shaping AI policy and regulation could undermine efforts to develop a thriving AI ecosystem.

Regulation is crucial in every industry, AI included, but implementing policies for hypothetical problems that may never occur will likely hinder progress made in the sector. An environment that continues to attract talent, investment, and in turn progress, must be maintained to ensure the UK advances its position as a key global player in the industry.

For more startup news, check out the other articles on the website, and subscribe to the magazine for free. Listen to The Cereal Entrepreneur podcast for more interviews with entrepreneurs and big-hitters in the startup ecosystem.