Outsider thinking: why rule breakers redefine what’s possible

Robert F. Kennedy captured the essence of breakthrough thinking: "Some men see things as they are and ask, 'Why?' I dream things that never were and ask, 'Why not?'"

This tension between what is and what could be drives all meaningful innovation. Imagination lifts us like hot air in a balloon, while experience anchors us with necessary weight – grounding our flights of fancy but also preventing us from soaring. The breakthrough happens when we know exactly which ballast to drop and which to keep.

So how do we defy convention and return to first principles? Especially in our age of Large Language Models, it starts with humility – recognising that while knowledge is limited, imagination can circle the world. Technology follows predictable trends that let us forecast everything from car efficiency to battery capacity. Moore's Law has guided computing for fifty years by observing that transistor density doubles every two years.

But these very trends also reveal where radical innovation can create entirely new trajectories.

The power of unconventional eyes

Every major leap starts with a simple question: Why does it have to work this way?

When you're trained outside a field orthodoxy, you operate from first principles rather than inherited assumptions. You focus on reimagining the possible rather than tweaking the known.

Using myself as an example, I am a laser engineer who wandered into the world of audio. Industry veterans had long accepted a trade-off: small speakers mean weaker sound. But as an outsider, I asked a different question: How can small speakers deliver powerful sound? That curious question led to a breakthrough: producing sound using ultrasonic waves instead of traditional speaker cones.

It took years of persistence, and plenty of healthy scepticism from the industry, for that unconventional idea to become a serious contender. Why? Because it followed an entirely new playbook. That's exactly what outsiders bring: fresh perspectives and the relentless drive to pursue them long after insiders have moved on to other priorities.

Beyond the "Eureka" myth

Hollywood loves the lone genius struck by lightning – the sudden flash of inspiration that changes everything. Reality is messier and far more inspiring. As Edison wisely observed: "Most people miss opportunity because it comes dressed in rags and looks like hard work." Breakthrough innovation emerges from the unglamorous grind of iteration, the daily discipline of testing one more hypothesis, and the wisdom to extract lessons from every failed attempt.

James Dyson didn't wake up one morning with the perfect vacuum design. He built 5,127 prototypes across five years, learning something essential from each failure. Edison didn't stumble upon the right lightbulb filament by accident – he systematically eliminated thousands of materials that didn't work. My own ultrasonic breakthrough came through countless cycles of modelling, building, testing, and rebuilding – each iteration revealing another piece of the puzzle.

The most transformative technologies emerge not from flashes of genius but from sustained curiosity paired with relentless execution. It's about showing up when inspiration fades, questioning one assumption at a time, and trusting that marginal improvements compound into revolutionary leaps.

How organisations unlock radical innovation

Clayton Christensen's "The Innovator's Dilemma" revealed a crucial insight: for radical innovation to flourish, organisations must free teams from existing constraints. The most striking example was IBM's approach to creating the PC. The team received just one requirement – put the IBM logo on the product. Everything else was up for grabs. No legacy systems to maintain, no existing customer expectations to satisfy, no established processes to follow.

This liberation from organisational baggage allowed IBM's team to break every rule in the computer industry playbook. They sourced components externally, used open architecture, and created something entirely different from IBM's mainframe DNA. The result wasn't just a successful product – it was a new category that redefined computing.

Today's smartest organisations recognise they can't innovate in isolation. They're embracing open innovation ecosystems and startup partnerships to access uncharted paths their internal teams might never explore. Rather than trying to think outside the box internally, they're bringing the outside in – partnering with startups that operate in entirely different boxes, acquiring companies that challenge their assumptions, and creating venture arms that place bets on technologies their core business would never touch.

The future belongs to organisations that master this balance: maintaining their core excellence while creating space for radical experiments that could make that core obsolete.

The next arms race: cognitive diversity

The beauty of fresh perspective is real: when you approach problems with a beginner's mind, you see possibilities that expertise can overlook. That's why the next decade of tech will be won by combining deep knowledge with fresh thinking.

This creates unprecedented opportunity for cognitive arbitrage – applying insights from one field to solve intractable problems in another. The breakthrough technologies of history have been created at the intersections: biology meets computing gave us neural networks, materials science meets energy produced photovoltaics, behavioural psychology meets interface design created the smartphone revolution. These convergence points work like riptide currents – you gain swimming capabilities in one field, then swim to the intersections where the real action happens. That's where outsider thinking becomes most valuable, because insiders from each field rarely venture into the spaces between.

The founder's advantage: Your unconventional path isn't a detour – it's your unique dataset. Every "irrelevant" experience, every industry you've touched, every problem you've encountered becomes part of your pattern recognition system. As Steve Jobs said, you can't connect the dots looking forward; you can only connect them looking backward. The question isn't whether your background fits the problem, but whether your background reveals solutions others can't see.

Trust that the dots will connect – they always do for those brave enough to swim between fields.

The industry imperative: as knowledge becomes a commodity in the age of AI, the greatest danger is the lure of tunnel vision. The status quo has become the highest-risk strategy. In a world of exponential change, the companies that survive won't be those that optimise existing models but those that recognise when the entire game is changing. A broken business model is best replaced with a new one, not optimised into oblivion. This means creating internal venture arms, acquiring seemingly irrelevant startups, and funding research that your core business would never touch.

The future belongs to those who see disciplines as rich sources of material and unfinished puzzles. And the best puzzles are solved by those who embrace questioning everything – including the box they're thinking outside of.

For more startup news, check out the other articles on the website, and subscribe to the magazine for free. Listen to The Cereal Entrepreneur podcast for more interviews with entrepreneurs and big-hitters in the startup ecosystem.