A wrong hire in a lean team doesn’t just slow things down, it warps culture, drains energy, and creates invisible decision drag. A great hire, on the other hand, amplifies you. They bring energy, resilience, and the right kind of friction to help you fly further.

This isn’t about scanning CVs or chasing big names. It’s about hiring for complementary thinking styles, emotional stamina, and the kind of team chemistry that fuels dopamine, not drama.

Let’s reframe your hiring process: from reactive seat-filling to strategic dopamine-matching.

Why traditional hiring misses the mark

Most early-stage hiring starts from skill gaps. You need someone to build, sell, code, or deliver. But skills alone aren’t enough. Cognitive style, energy regulation, and interpersonal dynamics are just as important, especially when your team is tiny and time is short.

Why? Because cognitive diversity is a proven asset in complex problem-solving. Teams with varied thinking preferences generate more ideas, make better decisions, and avoid groupthink.

Yet, founders often fall into the “mini-me” trap: hiring people who think, speak, and decide like them. It feels easier at first, but leads to cultural monoculture and blind spots down the line.

To scale smartly, you need to hire people who challenge your thinking and match your tempo.

Great hiring starts with great interviewing

Before you can grow a great team, you need to know how to run a great interview. It’s a skill most leaders are rarely taught, yet expected to master. And here’s the truth: every candidate you engage with,  successful or not,  becomes a walking advertisement for your company. Treat them with clarity and respect, and even those who don’t get the role will leave with a positive impression. In today’s connected world, everyone is a potential advocate, partner, or client. The way you hire shapes more than your team, it shapes your reputation.

Interviewing isn’t about ticking boxes, it’s about tuning in. Go in with three non-negotiable questions that help you assess core fit, but let the rest of the conversation flow. Be fully present. The best insights come when you actually listen, not when you power through a 20-question script.

Take a coaching approach: ask open-ended questions, follow the thread, and gently push for depth: “Tell me more about that,” or “What did you learn from it?” are golden. Always ask for real examples, stories reveal how someone really thinks, leads, or reacts under pressure.

Don’t forget: interviews are two-way. Have a clear, compelling elevator pitch about the role, the company and your leadership style to build rapport and set the tone. Finally, close the loop, clearly explain next steps and commit to follow-up. Even a short, thoughtful piece of feedback shows respect and protects your employer brand. Great interviews aren’t just about finding the right candidate. They’re about earning trust, even from the ones you don’t hire.

Step 1: hire for cognitive diversity, not just experience

When you’re building a lean team, you don’t just need smart people, you need different kinds of smart. Innovation thrives when people approach problems from varied angles, challenge each other’s blind spots, and bring different types of energy into the room.

While personality frameworks like MBTI can be useful development tools post-hire, they should never be used as  a recruitment tool or selection criteria. What can be explored during hiring, however, is how a candidate thinks under pressure, approaches decision-making, and responds to challenges.

In early-stage teams, energy match matters. You don’t want five visionaries and no finishers. Nor five meticulous executors with no appetite for risk. A well-calibrated team balances future-focused thinking with present-tense realism, logic with empathy, instinct with structure.

Practical tip – ask these in interviews to understand real-time thinking styles:

• “When facing a complex problem, do you start by exploring the big picture or working through details step by step?”
• “In high-stakes decisions, what holds more weight for you: data or team impact?”
• “Under pressure, do you tend to process internally or talk it through with others?”

Take each of these questions further by asking them to talk you through a recent example, always look for evidence! A great follow up question to all of these is: “that’s really interesting, tell me more”. Simple. Effective.

These responses help you sense how someone processes information, makes decisions, and recharges, essential insight for fast-paced collaboration. It’s not about finding someone just like you. It’s about building a team where differences drive momentum, not friction.

Step 2: screen for resilience, not just readiness

Skills can be trained. Mindset takes longer.

Research in resilience psychology shows that people with higher cognitive flexibility and emotional regulation perform better in uncertain, high-stakes environments. Sound familiar?

Startups are a breeding ground for ambiguity. So ask:

• “Tell me about a time when something important failed, what did you do next?”
• “What helps you reset after a tough day?”
• “What’s one belief that helps you thrive under pressure?”

You’re listening for ownership, adaptability, and resourcefulness, not just polished answers.

If you’re using case studies or assessments? Look beyond the solution. Watch how they think under pressure. Do they rush? Ask clarifying questions? Stay calm? These cues predict how they’ll perform when deadlines loom.

Step 3: onboard energy, not just tasks

Most founders underinvest in onboarding. It’s understandable, you’re stretched, and you’re hiring for relief. But a rushed onboarding costs you more later.

The goal of onboarding isn’t just knowledge transfer. It’s energy alignment.

→ Use this 3-part onboarding focus:

1. Tempo: how fast do we move? What does “urgent” mean here?
2. Decision-making: who owns what? When do we escalate?
3. Recovery culture: when and how do we rest, reset, or switch off?

These norms shape how your new hire spends their energy, and whether they feel safe to bring their whole self or constantly mask.

A deliberate onboarding conversation about these three points reduces misfires, boosts retention, and builds team resilience from day one.

Don’t hire culture fit. Hire culture add

It’s tempting to hire people you’d have a drink with. But that’s not enough.

Culture fit often means sameness. Culture add means difference that strengthens. Look for people who share your values, but bring a fresh lens, a different tempo, or a new way of framing decisions.

In neuroscience terms: you’re expanding the neural network of your company. Building a richer synaptic web. Avoid echo chambers. Build energetic range.

Because the future of your startup isn’t just the product. It’s the people building it.

TL;DR: your hiring playbook

• Map your thinking style and hire complementary, not cloned, cognitive types
• Screen for resilience using questions that reveal mindset under pressure
• Onboard energy habits, not just processes, tempo, decisions, recovery
• Prioritise culture add, not just fit, aim for psychological safety with diversity of thought

You don’t need a bloated team. You need the right dopamine match. The people who energise your mission, challenge your thinking, and sharpen your speed.

Hire with intention, and you’ll scale with stamina.

For more startup news, check out the other articles on the website, and subscribe to the magazine for free. Listen to The Cereal Entrepreneur podcast for more interviews with entrepreneurs and big-hitters in the startup ecosystem.