Having worked for over 14 years across finance, healthtech, and human capital management software – from Citibank to ADP – I’ve seen one truth hold firm: What gets measured gets managed. And in the case of QA, what gets measured also gets de-risked.

Below, I’ll break down why QA metrics are essential, which five metrics every startup product manager must track, and how to implement them without slowing innovation – all backed by real-world insight and lessons learned.

Why QA metrics are a startup’s secret weapon

QA metrics aren’t about bureaucracy – they’re about agility, adaptability, and insight. They help product managers:

• Predict failure points before they become user pain
• Learn from every release cycle
• Plan resources and timelines more accurately
• Adapt testing efforts based on real-time performance and user impact

Importantly, the right QA metrics measure outcomes, not just output. They reveal trends, encourage “good-enough” quality, and foster a culture of continuous improvement.

Metrics fall into two broad types:

• Process Metrics: how well testing and QA activities are being executed (e.g., test coverage, test execution rate)
• Product Metrics: how the product is performing in terms of quality (e.g., defect density, test effectiveness)

In one of my recent roles as a Quality Analyst Test Lead on an ERP system transformation project from serving small businesses to supporting complex, enterprise-level clients, we successfully applied both types across agile teams to guide prioritisation, improve delivery confidence, and enhance cross-functional collaboration.

Real-world example: avoiding a costly localisation breakdown

Let’s talk localisation – a seemingly minor task that, when overlooked, can fracture user trust.

During a global payroll product rollout that involved replacing a legacy system with a new payroll platform across the North America and EMEA (Europe, Middle East, and Africa) regions, the new system introduced integration capabilities with third-party applications. This enabled the business to gain a transparent and unified view of payroll data across multiple entities, to ensure quality, we used test design metrics tied to localisation standards to validate not just functionality, but cultural correctness – French date formats, diacritical characters, currency and number formatting.

Without this pre-emptive testing approach, those bugs would’ve surfaced post-launch – when fixing them would’ve cost twice as much, and damaged our credibility in new markets. The takeaway? QA metrics give foresight, not hindsight.

The top 5 QA metrics every startup product manager should track

Here are five actionable QA metrics that I believe every startup PM should monitor, no matter your product maturity:

Defect Density by Workstream

Pinpoints high-risk areas in the product. A must for scaling teams with parallel feature development.

Defect Density by Enabling Technology

Helps you spot recurring technical weaknesses – whether it's your frontend stack or a legacy backend module.

Defect Density by Severity

Not all bugs are equal. Tracking severity lets you focus on issues that truly impact the user experience.

Time to Fix

Measures responsiveness and engineering efficiency. Critical for time-sensitive releases and support issues.

Time to Deploy After QA Sign-Off

Reveals how fast QA feedback is turned into deployable code. Reducing lag here means faster iteration and ROI.

What these metrics really measure (and why it matters)

These aren't just vanity numbers – they're windows into how your team is performing, where your product is vulnerable, and what’s likely to break next if you don’t act.

In my experience, every metric tells a story: when I saw the number of planned stories completed steadily drop over two sprints, it wasn’t a failure – it was a red flag that we were overcommitting. That gave us the confidence to re-scope and ship a leaner but stronger MVP.

A spike in defects reopened after “fix” told us that we were too rushed in our regression testing. A tough conversation followed – but the trust it built across QA and Dev made every future release smoother.

Think of it this way: metrics help you see around corners. They let you talk less about blame and more about behaviour. They give product managers the language to speak to engineers, designers, and leadership in the same voice – rooted in facts, not frustration.

Here’s what you should really be watching:

Functionality Metrics

% Completed vs. Planned User Stories

Helps identify planning accuracy. If completion drops, it may not be a capacity issue – it might be clarity or scope creep.

# of Stories Moved to Backlog or Next Sprint

A high number here doesn’t always mean failure – it can signal that you’re learning fast and adjusting. That’s agility at work.

Mid-sprint Additions or Deletions

These metrics reflect team focus and stakeholder discipline. Too many changes? Your priorities are probably reactive, not strategic.

Quality Metrics

% Requirements with Linked Test Coverage

A requirement not covered by a test is a gamble. This is your coverage net. It doesn’t have to be 100% – just meaningful.

# of Open vs Closed Defects Per Sprint

Tracking this over time will show your team’s rhythm – are we squashing bugs faster than we’re introducing them?

% Tests Automated vs Manual

There’s no golden ratio – but if your team spends every sprint doing repetitive test work manually, it’s time to pause and invest in automation.

In short: Metrics don’t tell you what to do – but they make sure you’re asking the right questions.

Scale with metrics, not just intuition

If your startup is scaling, don’t leave quality to chance. Build the habits, metrics, and systems that make QA a competitive edge – not just a cost centre.

Start by tracking the five metrics above. Then layer in test automation, collaborative testing practices, and data-informed retrospectives. The result? A team that delivers faster without breaking trust.

For more startup news, check out the other articles on the website, and subscribe to the magazine for free. Listen to The Cereal Entrepreneur podcast for more interviews with entrepreneurs and big-hitters in the startup ecosystem.