Why the best startups need industry as much as they need investment
Adam Kosterka, Executive Director of Converge, Scotland's national academic entrepreneurship…
The UK has long been recognised for the strength of its universities, research capability, and entrepreneurial talent. Across the country, our academic institutions continue to produce world-class research, pioneering technologies, and breakthrough ideas capable of shaping industries and addressing some of society’s biggest challenges.
The UK should take pride in that strength, but as competition for investment and commercial leadership intensifies, celebrating the quality of our innovation base is not enough. We must ensure ideas emerging from our universities have the best possible chance of achieving commercial success.
Too often, innovators engage with industry only after a startup has formed, a product has been developed, or a business is preparing to launch. By then, key opportunities to shape innovation around real commercial demand may already have been lost.
The UK has serious ambitions to turn more of its academic excellence into high-growth businesses, but to make this happen at scale we must bring industry closer to researchers, founders, and university-born businesses at a much earlier stage in the innovation journey.
At Converge, we are seeing growing evidence that this approach is not only valuable, but increasingly necessary. Having supported over 1,000 aspiring founders during the past fifteen years we have observed first-hand the opportunities and barriers that emerge as innovators seek to translate research into successful businesses.
Across that experience, it is sometimes the case that the ventures that build the strongest commercial foundations are not those with the biggest budgets or the earliest access to investment but the businesses that engage with industry early, using those relationships to assess assumptions and refine their ideas before committing considerable time and resources.
This year alone, Converge received a record number of applications, with more than 120 academic entrepreneurs now participating in our programme as they continue their journey towards commercialisation, bringing forward ventures spanning life sciences, engineering, artificial intelligence, sustainability and advanced technologies.
While funding remains an essential part of the startup journey, one of the most familiar challenges facing early-stage ventures is not only a lack of investment but a lack of meaningful engagement with the sectors and industries their innovations are designed to serve.
This helps explain why some of the most promising university-led innovations struggle to achieve commercial traction despite strong research foundations. The underlying technology may be exceptional, but without early engagement with potential customers and industry partners, there is a risk that innovators develop solutions that do not fully align with the challenges businesses are actively seeking to address.
Many founders assume that strong research will naturally translate into commercial success, but in reality, the gap between technical excellence and market demand can often be wider than expected. Early industry engagement helps close that gap by ensuring innovations are shaped around genuine customer needs and commercial realities.
Our partnership with Orbital Marine Power offers a clear example of what this can look like in practice.
Through its support of Converge’s Blue Economy Prize, the Orkney-based company is helping to support university-led innovation linked to one of the UK’s most strategically important growth sectors.
By engaging directly with early-stage founders through mentorship, insight-sharing and sector expertise, Orbital will help shape promising innovations before they reach market while providing practical insight drawn from its own commercial experience.
This creates stronger and more commercially relevant ventures while also giving established businesses visibility of emerging technologies and entrepreneurial talent that may help shape the future of their sectors.
That kind of collaboration should increasingly become the norm. While this partnership sits within the blue economy, the principle applies across virtually every high growth sector the UK is seeking to develop.
Clean energy, life sciences, advanced manufacturing, and the space economy will all depend on stronger connections between research excellence and commercial application if the UK is to maximise its innovation potential.
The importance of this challenge is becoming increasingly clear as these sectors continue to evolve. With market requirements shifting and new commercial opportunities emerging, the startups best positioned to succeed will be those with early access to industry knowledge and real-world insight, not just at the point of commercialisation, but while their ideas are still taking shape.
Recognising this, organisations across the innovation ecosystem are increasingly focused on creating opportunities for founders and businesses to engage much earlier in the development process, helping strengthen the pipeline of future high growth ventures.
More broadly, this reflects a wider shift in how innovation ecosystems need to operate. The UK does not lack ideas; what we need to focus on is creating stronger pathways between research excellence and commercial success, ensuring innovators have access to industry insight while ideas are still taking shape, rather than only once they are seeking investment or preparing to commercialise.
Organisations operating at the intersection of academia, entrepreneurship, industry and investment have an increasingly significant role to play in creating those connections and ensuring promising innovations are given the strongest possible opportunity to succeed.
Fifteen years of supporting university entrepreneurs has demonstrated that the most successful ventures rarely emerge through research excellence alone, they are built through collaboration between innovators, industry and the wider ecosystem that supports them.
The next generation of high growth businesses is already taking shape in universities across the UK.
Those ventures will still need investment, but the businesses most likely to thrive will be those that engage with industry early, ensuring their innovations are shaped by real market opportunities from the outset.
For more startup news, check out the other articles on the website, and subscribe to the magazine for free. Listen to The Cereal Entrepreneur podcast for more interviews with entrepreneurs and big-hitters in the startup ecosystem.




